The Philly cheesesteak is more than just a sandwich; it is a cultural icon born on the street corners of South Philadelphia. Combining thinly sliced beef, melted cheese, and a crusty roll, it represents the pinnacle of American comfort food. While residents of the City of Brotherly Love will endlessly debate the merits of Pat’s vs. Geno’s, or the choice between Cheez Whiz and Provolone, the truth is that you can recreate this masterpiece in your own kitchen. Mastering the art of the steak sandwich requires attention to detail, specifically regarding the cut of meat, the preparation of the bread, and the technique used at the griddle.
Selecting the Right Cut of Beef
The foundation of any great Philly steak sandwich is the beef. Authentic recipes almost exclusively call for ribeye. Ribeye is favored because of its high fat content and marbling, which ensures that the meat remains tender and flavorful even when sliced paper-thin and cooked quickly over high heat. The fat renders down during the cooking process, essentially basting the meat in its own juices.
If ribeye is outside of your budget, top round or flank steak can serve as acceptable substitutes, but they lack the richness of the traditional cut. Regardless of the cut you choose, the secret to a professional-grade sandwich is the thickness—or rather, the thinness—of the slice. The meat should be shaved so thin that it cooks in seconds.
To achieve this at home without a commercial meat slicer, place your beef in the freezer for about 45 to 60 minutes. You don’t want it frozen solid, but firm enough that it doesn’t slide around under your knife. Use a very sharp chef’s knife to shave off the thinnest possible ribbons of beef against the grain. This ensures the fibers are short, resulting in a “melt-in-your-mouth” texture rather than a chewy one.
The Bread: The Unsung Hero
In Philadelphia, the bread is just as important as the meat. The traditional choice is an Amoroso’s hearth-baked roll. These rolls are famous for having a thin, slightly crunchy crust and a soft, airy interior that can soak up the beef juices without falling apart.
If you cannot find authentic Philly rolls, look for high-quality Italian hoagie rolls. Avoid soft, doughy “sub” rolls found in the bread aisle of most grocery stores, as they tend to become soggy and compressed under the weight of the hot beef and cheese. A good rule of thumb is to look for a roll that has some structural integrity but isn’t so hard that it scrapes the roof of your mouth. For the best results, lightly toast the inside of the roll on the griddle with a bit of butter or oil before assembling the sandwich.
Choosing Your Cheese
The “Cheese” in cheesesteak is a point of significant contention. There are three primary schools of thought:
-
Cheez Whiz
For many purists, “Whiz Wit” (Whiz with onions) is the only way to go. The processed cheese sauce provides a salty, creamy element that coats every morsel of beef. It creates a cohesive, messy, and delicious experience that defines the street-food version of the dish.
-
Provolone
For those who prefer a more “natural” cheese flavor, Provolone is the standard. A mild Provolone is best, as an aged or “sharp” Provolone can sometimes overpower the flavor of the beef. The heat from the meat should melt the slices until they become gooey and stretchy.
-
American Cheese
White American cheese is a popular middle ground. It has a high meltability factor similar to Whiz but offers a creamier, milder dairy flavor. Many high-end delis in Philly prefer American because it provides a silky texture that binds the meat together perfectly.
The Preparation: Onions and Peppers
While the “classic” cheesesteak is often just meat and cheese, the addition of onions is widely accepted. The onions should be diced or thinly sliced and sautéed until they are soft and translucent, bordering on caramelized.
Green bell peppers and mushrooms are common additions outside of Philadelphia, though they are often viewed as “extra” by locals. If you choose to include them, sauté them alongside the onions until they are tender. The goal is to have the vegetables integrated into the meat, not sitting on top of it as a separate garnish.
Step-by-Step Cooking Instructions
Success on the griddle comes down to heat management and speed. Follow these steps to ensure your sandwich is hot, juicy, and perfectly melted.
-
Preparing the Griddle
Heat a large flat-top griddle or a heavy cast-iron skillet over medium-high heat. You want the surface to be hot enough that a drop of water sizzles and evaporates instantly. Add a tablespoon of neutral oil (like vegetable or canola oil) to the surface. Avoid olive oil, as its smoke point is too low for this type of searing.
-
Sautéing the Aromatics
Add your onions (and peppers, if using) to the hot surface. Season them with a pinch of salt and pepper. Cook them, tossing frequently, until they are browned and soft. Once finished, move them to the cooler side of the griddle or remove them to a plate momentarily.
-
Searing the Beef
Add another splash of oil if the pan looks dry, then spread the shaved beef out in a thin layer. Let it sear undisturbed for about 60 seconds to develop a bit of a crust. Use a metal spatula to “chop” the meat as it cooks, breaking up any large clumps. This chopping action is a signature move of Philly grill cooks; it creates more surface area for browning and ensures the meat is easy to bite through.
-
The Assembly
Once the beef is no longer pink, mix the sautéed onions back into the meat pile. Shape the meat into a long rectangle that roughly matches the length and width of your roll. Lay your slices of cheese (Provolone or American) directly on top of the meat. If using Cheez Whiz, you can spread it directly onto the bread or drizzle it over the meat now.
Open your roll and place it face-down over the pile of meat and melting cheese. This allows the steam from the meat to soften the bread and helps the cheese “grip” the roll. After about 30 seconds, slide a long spatula under the beef and, in one swift motion, flip the entire thing over so the meat and cheese are now inside the sandwich.
-
Seasoning and Finishing Touches
A common mistake is under-seasoning the beef. Because the meat is cooked so quickly, you need to be generous with salt and black pepper while it is on the griddle. Some people like to add a dash of garlic powder or a splash of Worcestershire sauce for extra depth, though this moves away from the traditional flavor profile.
For a “Hoagie” style cheesesteak, you can add shredded lettuce, sliced tomatoes, and raw onions to the sandwich after the meat is added. Hot cherry peppers or sweet peppers are also popular toppings offered on the side or directly in the sandwich to add a vinegary crunch that cuts through the richness of the fat.
Pro Tips for the Home Cook
To take your sandwich to the next level, consider these professional secrets:
- Never use pre-cooked or frozen “steak strips” from a box. These are often processed and lack the texture of fresh ribeye.
- If your meat is releasing too much moisture and “boiling” instead of searing, you are likely crowding the pan. Work in batches or use a larger cooking surface.
- Use a heavy-weight spatula. The ability to firmly press and chop the meat is essential for that authentic texture.
- Don’t be afraid of the grease. The fat is where the flavor lives. If you drain the meat too thoroughly, you’ll end up with a dry, bland sandwich.
FAQs
-
What is the best meat for a Philly cheesesteak?
The gold standard is ribeye steak. Its high fat-to-meat ratio ensures the sandwich is juicy and flavorful. If ribeye is unavailable, top round is a leaner but acceptable alternative, provided it is sliced extremely thin.
-
Do I have to use Cheez Whiz?
No. While Cheez Whiz is a popular choice in Philadelphia, Provolone and American cheese are equally traditional and widely available at almost every steak shop in the city.
-
Can I make this in a regular frying pan?
Yes, a cast-iron skillet or a large stainless steel frying pan works well. The key is to ensure the pan is very hot before adding the meat so that you get a good sear rather than steaming the beef.
-
How do I get the meat thin enough without a slicer?
Partial freezing is the best method for home cooks. Freeze the beef for about 45 minutes until it is firm but not rock-solid. This allows you to use a sharp knife to shave off paper-thin slices with precision.
-
What makes it a “Philly” steak versus just a steak sandwich?
A Philly steak is defined by the specific combination of thinly shaved beef (usually ribeye), melted cheese (Whiz, Provolone, or American), and a specific type of long, crusty-yet-soft Italian roll. The technique of chopping the meat on the griddle and melting the cheese directly onto the beef before “cupping” it with the bread is what creates the authentic texture and flavor profile.