The Philly cheesesteak is more than just a sandwich; it is a cultural icon born on the streets of South Philadelphia. For the uninitiated, it consists of thinly sliced beef, melted cheese, and a long, crusty-yet-soft hoagie roll. While you can find variations of this sandwich in almost every corner of the world, making an authentic version at home requires a specific set of techniques and ingredients.
To achieve that signature “Philly” taste, you have to focus on the quality of the beef, the texture of the bread, and the way the cheese binds everything together. Whether you prefer yours “wit” onions or “witout,” this guide will walk you through every step to ensure your kitchen smells like a classic Italian Market steak shop.
Choosing the Best Cut of Meat
The foundation of any great cheesesteak is the beef. In Philadelphia, the gold standard is ribeye. Ribeye is favored because it has a high fat content and beautiful marbling, which ensures the meat stays juicy and flavorful even when it is sliced paper-thin and cooked quickly over high heat.
If ribeye is out of your budget, you can substitute it with top sirloin or even a high-quality flank steak. However, keep in mind that leaner cuts can become chewy if overcooked. If you are using a leaner cut, you may need to add a bit more oil to the pan to mimic the richness of the ribeye fat. Regardless of the cut, the most important factor is how you slice it.
The Secret to Thinly Sliced Beef
You cannot simply chop up a steak and call it a cheesesteak. The meat must be sliced so thin that it almost becomes translucent ribbons. The easiest way to achieve this at home without a commercial deli slicer is to use your freezer.
Place your steak in the freezer for about 45 to 60 minutes. You do not want it frozen solid, but you want it firm enough that it does not slide around under your knife. Once the meat is chilled and firm, use a very sharp chef’s knife to shave the meat against the grain into the thinnest possible slices. After slicing, some home cooks prefer to give the meat a rough chop with their spatulas while it is on the griddle to create that classic “chipped” texture.
Selecting the Right Bread
In Philadelphia, the bread is just as important as the meat. Most locals insist on Amoroso’s rolls, which are known for having a soft, pillowy interior and a slightly chewy crust that can hold up to the grease and weight of the steak.
If you cannot find Amoroso’s, look for high-quality Italian hoagie rolls or sub rolls. Avoid crusty baguettes or sourdough, as they are often too hard and will cause the filling to squeeze out the back when you take a bite. You want a roll that “gives” a little but does not fall apart. Pro tip: To make your sandwich even better, lightly butter the inside of the roll and toast it on the griddle before adding the meat.
The Great Cheese Debate: Provolone vs. Whiz
There is an eternal debate in the cheesesteak world: Provolone, American, or Cheez Whiz?
Provolone offers a sophisticated, slightly sharp flavor that cuts through the richness of the beef. If you choose provolone, look for a mild, non-aged version so it melts smoothly. White American cheese is perhaps the most popular choice for locals because it is incredibly creamy and melts into every nook and cranny of the chopped meat.
Then, there is Cheez Whiz. While often seen as a tourist choice, it is undeniably authentic. The “Whiz” provides a salty, liquid-gold consistency that binds the meat and onions into a singular, decadent mass. At home, you can simply warm the Whiz in a small saucepan and drizzle it over the meat once it is piled into the roll.
Preparing the Onions and Toppings
The traditional topping for a cheesesteak is fried onions. You should use yellow or sweet onions, chopped or sliced into thin rings. Sauté them in oil or butter over medium heat until they are soft and translucent with just a hint of caramelization.
While purists argue that peppers and mushrooms do not belong on a “real” Philly cheesesteak, many people enjoy the added texture. If you are adding bell peppers or mushrooms, sauté them separately from the meat first, then set them aside. You will incorporate them back into the meat just before adding the cheese to ensure everything is hot and well-integrated.
Step-by-Step Cooking Process
- To begin, heat a large cast-iron skillet or a flat-top griddle over medium-high heat. Add a tablespoon of vegetable oil. If you are making your sandwich “wit,” add your onions first and cook them until they are softened. Move them to the side of the pan.
- Add another splash of oil to the hottest part of the pan and lay down your thinly sliced beef in a single layer. Let it sear for about 1 to 2 minutes until browned on one side. Use a heavy-duty metal spatula to flip the meat and then start chopping it into smaller pieces right on the griddle.
- Once the meat is no longer pink, season it simply with salt and pepper. Incorporate the onions back into the meat and shape the mixture into a long rectangle roughly the size of your hoagie roll. Lay two to three slices of cheese over the top of the meat pile. If using Cheez Whiz, wait until the assembly stage.
- Place your opened hoagie roll face-down over the melting cheese and meat. This allows the steam from the meat to soften the bread while the cheese acts as a glue. After about 30 seconds, slide your spatula under the meat and flip the whole thing over as you lift it off the griddle, tucking any stray pieces of beef into the roll.
Serving and Customizing
A Philly cheesesteak is best served immediately while the cheese is still gooey and the bread is warm. In Philadelphia, common condiments include ketchup, hot cherry peppers, or even a bit of mayonnaise. If you add lettuce and tomato, you have created what is known as a “Cheesesteak Hoagie,” which provides a refreshing, cool contrast to the hot meat.
FAQs
-
What is the best cut of meat for a Philly cheesesteak?
The most authentic and flavorful cut is ribeye. Its high fat content ensures the meat stays tender and juicy during the quick, high-heat cooking process. If ribeye is unavailable, top sirloin is a common and delicious alternative.
-
How do I get the meat thin enough at home?
The best trick is to place the beef in the freezer for 45 to 60 minutes before slicing. This firms up the muscle fibers, allowing you to use a sharp knife to shave the meat into paper-thin ribbons without it tearing or sliding.
-
Can I use a regular frying pan if I don’t have a griddle?
Yes, a large cast-iron skillet is an excellent substitute for a griddle because it retains heat well and provides a good sear. Avoid non-stick pans if possible, as they don’t allow the meat to get those desirable crispy, browned edges.
-
Is Cheez Whiz really authentic?
Yes, Cheez Whiz has been a staple in Philadelphia steak shops since the 1950s. While some locals prefer American or Provolone, “Whiz Wit” (Whiz with onions) is one of the most common ways to order a cheesesteak in the city.
-
Should I put bell peppers on my cheesesteak?
While popular in many parts of the country, green bell peppers are actually not part of a “traditional” Philly cheesesteak. However, many shops in Philly offer them as an add-on. If you enjoy them, there is no rule against adding them to your homemade version.