Pomegranates are often referred to as the jewels of the winter fruit season. Their vibrant red arils provide a burst of tart, sweet juice and a satisfying crunch. However, unlike an apple or a banana, a pomegranate does not give away its quality easily. The thick, leathery skin hides the treasure inside, making it difficult to tell if you are bringing home a prize or a dud. Learning how to pick a pomegranate is a skill that combines visual cues, tactile feedback, and a bit of weight assessment. When you master these techniques, you ensure that every fruit you crack open is filled with ruby-red, juice-heavy seeds rather than pale, dry ones.
Look for Geometric Shapes Over Perfect Rounds
One of the most common mistakes people make when choosing a pomegranate is looking for a perfectly round, sphere-like fruit. While a round shape is desirable for many fruits, it is actually a sign of immaturity for a pomegranate.
As a pomegranate ripens, the seeds inside expand and fill with juice. These expanding arils push against the outer walls of the fruit. This internal pressure causes the skin to tighten and the fruit to take on a more angular, flattened, or “squared-off” appearance. When you are browsing the produce aisle, look for pomegranates that have distinct ridges or a hexagonal shape. These edges indicate that the seeds are bulging with juice and have reached their peak maturity.
Assess the Weight and Density
The most reliable way to determine the juiciness of a pomegranate is by its weight. Because the edible portion of the fruit consists almost entirely of liquid-filled seeds, a ripe pomegranate should feel surprisingly heavy for its size.
When you pick up a pomegranate, compare it to others of a similar diameter. Always choose the one that feels the densest. A heavy fruit suggests that the arils are fully developed and haven’t begun to dry out. If a pomegranate feels light or hollow, it is likely past its prime or was picked too early. The “heaviness” is a direct correlation to the volume of juice you will eventually extract.
Examine the Skin Color and Texture
While color is not the only indicator of ripeness, it provides important clues. Pomegranates can range in color from a light pinkish-red to a deep, dark burgundy. Generally, a deeper red indicates a more mature fruit, but this can vary by variety.
Instead of focusing solely on the shade of red, look at the texture and “sheen” of the skin. A ripe pomegranate will have skin that is firm and tough, similar to leather. You want to avoid skin that looks overly shiny or waxy, as this can sometimes indicate an underripe fruit. Instead, look for a matte finish or skin that appears slightly stretched and thin.
Be on the lookout for minor scratches or scars on the surface. These are often just “orchard scars” caused by branches rubbing against the fruit in the wind. These blemishes do not affect the quality of the seeds inside. However, you should strictly avoid pomegranates with soft spots, mold, or deep cracks that expose the interior, as these are signs of decay.
Check the Blossom End
The blossom end, or the “crown” of the pomegranate, can also give you a hint about its condition. The crown should be healthy and free of fuzzy mold. If the crown looks shriveled or dark brown, the fruit may have been sitting in storage for too long. A fresh-looking crown usually indicates a fresher fruit.
The Scratch Test
If you are still unsure, you can perform a very subtle scratch test with your fingernail. A ripe pomegranate has skin that is relatively easy to scratch because it has become thin and taut. If the skin is very hard and impossible to mark, it might be underripe. If the skin feels soft and mushy when you press it, the fruit is likely overripe or rotting. The ideal fruit is firm to the touch but has skin that feels like it is under tension from the seeds within.
Proper Storage for Your Selection
Once you have used these tips to pick the perfect pomegranate, you want to make sure it stays fresh. Pomegranates have a surprisingly long shelf life compared to other fruits.
- Room Temperature: If you plan to eat the fruit within a week, you can keep it on the counter out of direct sunlight.
- Refrigeration: To extend the life of the fruit, place it in a plastic bag in the refrigerator. Whole pomegranates can last for up to two months when kept chilled.
- Arils: Once you have removed the seeds, they should be stored in an airtight container in the fridge, where they will stay fresh for about five days. You can also freeze the arils by spreading them on a baking sheet to freeze individually before transferring them to a freezer-safe bag.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Can pomegranates ripen after they are picked?
No, pomegranates do not continue to ripen or get sweeter once they have been harvested from the tree. This is why it is crucial to use the “angular shape” and “weight” tests at the store to ensure you are buying a fruit that was picked at the peak of maturity.
-
What does it mean if my pomegranate has a large crack in it?
Small, superficial cracks are sometimes okay, but large cracks usually mean the fruit has dried out or been exposed to too much moisture during growth. Cracks also provide an entry point for bacteria and mold. It is best to avoid cracked pomegranates when shopping.
-
Are smaller pomegranates less sweet than larger ones?
Size does not necessarily dictate sweetness. A small pomegranate can be just as sweet as a large one, provided it is heavy for its size and has an angular shape. Choose the size that fits your needs, but always prioritize density.
-
Why are some pomegranates pink instead of dark red?
Some specific varieties of pomegranates, such as the “Wonderful” variety, are naturally darker. Others, like the “Ariana” or “Gissarskii Rozovyi,” may be lighter pink or even yellowish on the outside even when fully ripe. However, in most standard grocery stores, a deeper red color is the standard indicator of ripeness.
-
How can I tell if the seeds inside have gone bad?
When you open the fruit, the arils should be plump and translucent. If the seeds are brown, slimy, or have a fermented smell like alcohol, the fruit has spoiled and should be discarded. Healthy seeds should look like bright, firm jewels.