The arrival of the Lenten season often signals a shift in the fast-food landscape, as chains pivot from their standard beef and chicken offerings to highlight seafood. Among the most anticipated returns is the seasonal lineup from Arby’s. Known primarily for their slogan “We Have The Meats,” Arby’s consistently proves that “the meats” includes high-quality fish during the early months of the year. If you are planning your next drive-thru run, you are likely wondering about the current financial investment required to satisfy that crispy seafood craving.
Navigating the menu can be a bit more complex than just looking for a single price tag. Between regional price variations, various sandwich builds, and the highly sought-after “2 for” deals, the cost of an Arby’s fish sandwich can range anywhere from a few dollars to a double-digit meal price. In 2026, Arby’s has maintained its reputation for offering substantial portions, but inflation and delivery service fees have influenced the final number on your receipt.
Pricing for the Classic Crispy Fish Sandwich
The entry point for the seasonal seafood menu is the Arby’s Crispy Fish Sandwich. This item is the foundation of their fish offerings, featuring a wild-caught Alaskan Pollock fillet that is battered and fried until golden brown. It is topped with tartar sauce and shredded iceberg lettuce, all served on a toasted sesame seed bun.
For those purchasing just the sandwich at a physical restaurant location, the price typically hovers around $5.29 to $6.19. In many standard markets, $6.19 has become the baseline for the individual sandwich as of early 2026. This price reflects the rising costs of seafood and logistics, yet it remains competitive when compared to premium offerings from other major fast-food players.
If you choose to upgrade this to a meal, which includes a side—traditionally Arby’s famous curly fries or the newer crinkle-cut option—and a small drink, you can expect the price to land between $9.50 and $11.00. The variation here depends heavily on your geographic location. For instance, a franchise in a high-cost urban area like New York or San Francisco will likely charge at the higher end of that spectrum, whereas a location in the Midwest or South may lean toward the $9.50 mark.
The Premium Choice: King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe Sandwich
For diners looking for a more elevated experience, Arby’s offers the King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe Sandwich. This version swaps the standard sesame bun for a sweet, airy King’s Hawaiian roll and adds a few extra toppings to the mix. In addition to the crispy fish fillet and tartar sauce, the Deluxe version includes a slice of sharp cheddar cheese and a fresh tomato slice.
Because of the premium ingredients and the branding partnership with King’s Hawaiian, this sandwich carries a higher price point. On average, the King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe Sandwich retails for approximately $6.69 to $7.09 when purchased individually.
When bundled into a meal, the price for the Deluxe version usually sits around $11.50 to $13.00. While the jump in price might seem significant, many fans of the chain argue that the sweetness of the Hawaiian bun paired with the salty, savory fish fillet creates a flavor profile that justifies the extra dollar.
Leveraging the 2 for $7 Mix and Match Deal
One of the most effective ways to lower the per-sandwich cost is to take advantage of Arby’s legendary “mix and match” value deals. In early 2026, Arby’s has promoted a “2 for $7” deal that frequently includes the Crispy Fish Sandwich as an eligible item.
Under this promotion, you can purchase two Crispy Fish Sandwiches for $7.00, bringing the cost per sandwich down to just $3.50. This is a massive discount compared to the $6.19 individual price. Alternatively, many locations allow for “Surf and Turf” combinations, where you can pair a fish sandwich with a Classic Roast Beef or a Beef ‘n Cheddar for the same $7.00 price point.
It is important to note that the King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe is rarely included in the 2 for $7 deal due to its higher ingredient costs. However, for the budget-conscious consumer, the standard Crispy Fish Sandwich via the mix and match deal represents some of the best value currently available in the fast-food industry.
Delivery App Pricing and Hidden Fees
If you are ordering your fish sandwich through a third-party delivery service like Uber Eats, DoorDash, or Grubhub, the price will look markedly different. These platforms often list menu items at a markup to help cover the commissions charged to the restaurant.
In many instances, the $6.19 Crispy Fish Sandwich might be listed for as much as $11.65 on a delivery app, while the King’s Hawaiian version can climb to over $13.00 for just the sandwich. This does not include delivery fees, service fees, or the tip for the driver. When ordering via delivery, a single fish sandwich meal can easily exceed $20.00. To get the best price, ordering directly through the Arby’s app for in-store pickup is usually the most cost-effective method, as the app often features exclusive coupons and rewards points that cannot be found elsewhere.
Nutritional Value and What You Get for Your Money
Understanding the cost also involves looking at the value provided in terms of sustenance. The Arby’s Crispy Fish Sandwich is not a light snack; it is a substantial meal.
A standard Crispy Fish Sandwich weighs approximately 228 grams and contains about 570 calories. It provides 20 grams of protein and 25 grams of fat. When analyzed by weight, the sandwich often measures out to be larger than the competitors’ fish offerings, which frequently use smaller, square-shaped patties. Arby’s uses a more natural-looking fillet that often extends beyond the edges of the bun.
The King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe is even more substantial, coming in at roughly 690 calories due to the added cheese, tomato, and the denser, sweeter bun. For the price, you are receiving a high-calorie, high-protein meal that is designed to be filling, which is a key metric for many fast-food consumers evaluating “value for money.”
Regional Variations and Franchise Rights
Because Arby’s operates on a franchise model, individual owners have a certain amount of leeway when it comes to pricing. While the corporate office suggests a price, a franchise owner in a high-rent district or an area with high labor costs may increase prices to maintain their margins.
Furthermore, some promotional deals like the 2 for $7 might not be available at every single location. Airport Arby’s locations, highway rest stops, and non-traditional venues (like those inside malls or universities) are notorious for having higher prices and opting out of national value promotions. Always check the local menu or the Arby’s mobile app to confirm the exact pricing for your specific zip code before you head out.
Quality Control and Preparation Standards
Part of the cost of an Arby’s fish sandwich goes toward the preparation process. Unlike some competitors who might keep fish fillets in a warming cabinet for extended periods, Arby’s emphasizes a “made-to-order” approach during peak Lenten hours to ensure the breading stays crispy.
The fish is cooked at high temperatures to ensure safety and texture. Internal quality checks typically require the fish to be served at or above 140°F to maintain food safety standards and the intended eating experience. The lettuce is shredded fresh, and the buns are toasted on-site, contributing to the overall cost of labor and operations reflected in the menu price.
The Seasonal Nature of the Menu
The final factor influencing the cost is the limited-time nature of these items. Because Arby’s does not carry fish year-round at most locations, they do not benefit from the same permanent supply chain efficiencies as their roast beef products. The logistical effort to bring wild-caught Alaskan Pollock into thousands of stores for just a few months a year adds a premium to the price.
However, this scarcity also creates high demand. Fans of the sandwich often wait all year for its return, and the pricing strategy reflects a balance between making the item accessible through deals and capitalizing on its status as a seasonal favorite.
FAQs
-
How long does Arby’s keep fish sandwiches on the menu?
Arby’s typically brings back their fish sandwiches in late December or early January to coincide with the start of the Lenten season. They usually remain on the menu through Easter Sunday. Once the Lenten season concludes, the items are removed to make room for other seasonal rotations, though some high-volume locations may carry them slightly longer depending on remaining stock.
-
Is the Arby’s fish sandwich made with real fish?
Yes, Arby’s uses 100% wild-caught Alaskan Pollock for their fish sandwiches. The fish is sustainably sourced and processed into fillets which are then coated in a crispy breading. It is considered a step up in quality from the “minced fish” patties used by some lower-cost competitors.
-
Can I customize my Arby’s fish sandwich?
Absolutely. While the standard build includes tartar sauce and lettuce, you can add or remove any ingredients. Common customizations include adding a slice of American or Cheddar cheese, adding pickles, or swapping the tartar sauce for Arby’s Sauce or Horsey Sauce. Some locations may even allow you to put the fish fillet on a different type of bun, such as a brioche or a sub roll, for a small additional charge.
-
Does Arby’s offer any spicy version of the fish sandwich?
In previous years, Arby’s has released a “Spicy Fish Sandwich” featuring a spicy seasoning in the breading and spicy “Fiery” sauce. As of 2026, the availability of the spicy version varies by region. If it is not on the main menu, you can often mimic the flavor by asking for a side of Buffalo sauce or adding jalapeños to your order.
-
Why is the Arby’s fish sandwich more expensive than the McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish?
The Arby’s fish sandwich is generally larger and uses a more substantial fillet of Alaskan Pollock compared to the McDonald’s version. Additionally, Arby’s uses a larger sesame seed bun and more fresh toppings. The higher price point reflects the larger portion size and the premium nature of the ingredients used in the assembly of the sandwich.