The Monte Cristo sandwich is a masterpiece of culinary contrast. It sits perfectly at the intersection of breakfast and lunch, savory and sweet, and crunchy and soft. Often described as a cross between a classic ham and cheese melt and a slice of French toast, this sandwich has earned its place as a staple in diners and high-end bistros alike. While it might look intimidating with its golden-brown exterior and powdered sugar dusting, mastering how to make a Monte Cristo sandwich is surprisingly simple once you understand the basic techniques and the importance of layering flavors.
The History and Evolution of a Classic
To truly appreciate the Monte Cristo, it helps to know where it came from. Most food historians agree that it is an Americanized version of the French croque monsieur. The French version, which appeared on Paris cafe menus as early as 1910, consists of ham and Gruyère cheese grilled between slices of brioche.
By the 1930s and 1940s, American cookbooks began featuring “French Toasted Sandwiches.” However, the name “Monte Cristo” didn’t gain widespread popularity until the 1960s, notably after it was featured on the menu at the Blue Bayou Restaurant in Disneyland. Since then, it has evolved into various regional styles, some deep-fried in batter and others simply pan-seared in butter.
Essential Ingredients for the Perfect Monte Cristo
The quality of your sandwich depends entirely on the components you choose. Because this recipe relies on a few key items, choosing premium ingredients will significantly elevate the final result.
The Bread
You need a bread that is sturdy enough to handle a custard soak without falling apart. Thick-sliced brioche is the gold standard because of its high egg and butter content, which complements the French toast style. Challah is another excellent choice. If you prefer a more traditional sandwich texture, a thick-cut Texas toast will also work well.
The Proteins
A traditional Monte Cristo features two types of meat: thinly sliced deli ham and turkey breast. Honey-roasted ham adds a nice sweetness, while smoked turkey provides a savory depth. The key is to use very thin slices so you can layer them effectively, ensuring the heat penetrates to the center of the sandwich.
The Cheese
Swiss cheese is the traditional choice for its excellent melting properties and slightly nutty flavor. Gruyère is a sophisticated upgrade if you want a more authentic French flair. Some modern versions use Provolone or even Muenster for a milder, creamier pull.
The Custard Dip
This is what transforms a sandwich into a Monte Cristo. You will need:
- Large eggs
- Whole milk or heavy cream
- A pinch of salt
- A dash of nutmeg or cinnamon (optional, for a sweeter profile)
- A teaspoon of Dijon mustard (optional, mixed into the egg for a savory kick)
Step by Step Instructions on How to Make a Monte Cristo Sandwich
-
Preparing the Sandwich Assembly
Start by laying out your bread slices in pairs. Spread a thin layer of mayonnaise or Dijon mustard on the interior sides of the bread. This acts as “glue” and adds moisture. Place a slice of cheese on each piece of bread. Layer the ham and turkey between the cheese slices. Placing the meat in the middle ensures the cheese melts directly against the bread, creating a structural bond. Close the sandwich and press down firmly with your palm to compress the layers. -
Mixing the Batter
In a shallow bowl wide enough to fit the sandwich, whisk together two eggs and a quarter cup of milk. If you prefer a savory sandwich, add a pinch of black pepper. If you want the classic diner style, add a drop of vanilla extract. Whisk until the mixture is completely homogenous with no visible streaks of egg white. -
The Soaking Process
Heat a non-stick skillet or a heavy cast-iron pan over medium-low heat. Add a tablespoon of butter and a teaspoon of neutral oil (like canola) to prevent the butter from burning. Take your assembled sandwich and dip it into the egg mixture. Hold it in the liquid for about 10 seconds per side. You want the bread to absorb the custard but not become so soggy that it loses its shape. Don’t forget to quickly dip the edges of the sandwich into the batter as well. -
Frying to Perfection
Place the sandwich into the hot skillet. Cook for about 3 to 4 minutes on the first side. Resist the urge to flip it too early; you are looking for a deep, golden-brown crust. Once flipped, cook for another 3 minutes. If the bread is browning too quickly before the cheese has melted, lower the heat and cover the pan with a lid for one minute to trap the steam.
Serving Suggestions and Garnishes
The presentation of a Monte Cristo is just as iconic as its taste. Once the sandwich is removed from the pan, let it rest for sixty seconds on a cutting board. This allows the cheese to set slightly so it doesn’t all run out when you cut it.
Slice the sandwich diagonally to create two triangles. Traditionally, the Monte Cristo is dusted generously with powdered sugar. While this might seem odd for a meat sandwich, the sugar interacts with the salty ham to create a complex flavor profile.
Serve the sandwich with a small ramekin of raspberry preserves or blackberry jam on the side for dipping. The acidity and sweetness of the fruit cut through the richness of the fried bread and melted cheese.
Pro Tips for Success
-
If you are making sandwiches for a large group, don’t try to fry them all at once. You can sear them in the pan to get the crust started and then finish them in an oven preheated to 350 degrees Fahrenheit for about 5 to 7 minutes. This ensures the centers are hot and the cheese is bubbly without burning the exterior.
-
Always use a combination of butter and oil in your pan. Butter provides the flavor and that classic “browned butter” aroma, but it has a low smoke point. Adding a little bit of oil allows you to cook at the proper temperature for long enough to heat the interior of the sandwich without the butter turning black and bitter.
-
For an extra-decadent version, some chefs use a tempura-style batter instead of a French toast soak. This involves dipping the sandwich in a flour and club soda batter before deep frying. While delicious, the pan-seared method remains the most popular for home cooks because it is less messy and allows for better control over the texture.
FAQs
- What is the difference between a Monte Cristo and a Croque Monsieur?
- While both involve ham, cheese, and toasted bread, the Croque Monsieur is typically topped with a Béchamel sauce and more cheese before being broiled. The Monte Cristo is dipped in an egg batter and fried, similar to French toast, and is usually served with sweet accompaniments like powdered sugar and jam.
- Can I make a Monte Cristo in an air fryer?
- Yes, you can adapt this for an air fryer. Prepare the sandwich and dip it in the egg wash as usual. Lightly spray the air fryer basket with oil and cook at 375 degrees Fahrenheit for about 5 minutes per side. Note that the texture will be slightly less “custardy” and more “crispy” compared to the pan-fried version.
- Why is my Monte Cristo soggy in the middle?
- Sogginess usually happens for two reasons: either the bread was soaked for too long, or the cooking temperature was too high. If the heat is too high, the outside burns before the heat can reach the center to “set” the egg and melt the cheese. Cooking on medium-low heat is the best way to ensure a fully cooked interior.
- What kind of meat is best for this sandwich?
- The classic recipe calls for a combination of boiled or honey ham and roasted turkey breast. However, you can use left-over holiday ham or even roast beef. The most important factor is that the meat is sliced thin so that the sandwich remains easy to bite and the heat can penetrate the layers easily.
- Is the raspberry jam necessary?
- While not “necessary,” the jam is a traditional component that provides a vital flavor balance. The Monte Cristo is very rich and salty; the tartness of the raspberry or blackberry jam provides a counterpoint that makes the sandwich feel less heavy. If you don’t like berries, a spicy pepper jelly or even a bit of maple syrup can serve as a substitute.